Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Energy-Telecom Service Review per requirements

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #61
    1. “Email” field has an asterisk assigned but does not work as required field.
    2. “Referred by” field act as required but does not have asterisk.
    3. “First name” field accept 30 characters.
    4. “Last name” field accept 30 characters.
    5. “Zip” field accept letters.
    6. “Clear” button does not clear the form.
    7. “Clear” button invokes misleading error massage “Invalid Data”.
    8. No default button in the form.
    9. Cell phone service: “Current provider” list box “Other” option is needed.

    Comment


    • #62
      #1. Contact information: "First name" field accepts no more than 30 characters
      #2. Contact information: "Last name" field accepts no more than 30 characters
      #3. Contact information: "State" selector: States are not in alphabetic order.
      #4. Contact information: "State" selector: contains "Other", "BC"(British Columbia - Canada)
      #5. Contact information: "State" selector: replace "IND" with "IN"
      #6. Contact information: "Email" field must be required.
      #7. Contact information: "Referred by" field is not as required
      #8. Cell Phone Service: "Current Provider" selector is missing "AT&T"
      #9. Cell Phone Service: "Current Provider" selector is missing "Other"
      #10. Cell Phone Service: "My monthly bill is approximately" selector accepts non-digits.
      #11. Cell Phone service: "Months left on current program" must be in 0-23 range
      #12. Local/Long Distances/International Service: "My monthly Bill is approximately" field must accept only five digits
      #13. Local/Long Distances/International Service: "Total Bill" field must accept only five digits
      #14. High Speed Internet Service: "My monthly Bill is approximately" field must accept only five digits
      #15. Home Security Service: Current provider" selector: the names are not in alphabetic order.
      #16. Gas and Electric Services" table: replace "Opento" with "open to"
      #10. Clear" button brings error message.

      Comment


      • #63
        wow that is a thorough approach! I'm inspired!!

        Originally posted by denis-wittich View Post
        "Energy-Telecom Service Review" bug report - using web form testing guidelines
        OS: Windows 10 Pro (64-bit)
        Browser: Google Chrome 63.0.3239.132 (Official Build) (64-bit)

        #1. Contact Information: “Email:" text field should be assigned as a required field;
        #2. Contact Information: "Reffered by:" text field shouldn't be assigned as a required field;
        #3. Contact Information: “First Name:” text field accepts only 30 characters, should accept no more than 31 per requirement;
        #4. Contact Information: “Last Name:” text field accepts only 30 characters, should accept no more than 31 per requirement;
        #5. Contact Information: “Street Address:” text field accepts only 100 characters, should accept no more than 255 per requirement;
        #6. Contact Information: "State:" dropdown list: remove "BC" because it's a non-US state;
        #7. Contact Information: "State:" dropdown list box: remove "Other" from the list;
        #8. Contact Information: "State:" dropdown list box: replace "IND" with "IN" (right abbreviation for the State of Indiana);
        #9. Contact Information: "State:" dropdown list box: HI and NV states are missing;
        #10. Contact Information: “State:” dropdown list shows state names not in alphabetical order;
        #11. Contact Information: “ZIP:” text field accepts non-digits;
        #12. Contact Information: “Email:” text field accepts wrong email format (without “@” and “.”). No error message after submitting the form;
        #13. Contact Information: “Best way to contact me:” text should be in one line;

        #14. Cell Phone Service: “Current Provider:” dropdown list: provider names should be in alphabetical order;
        #15. Cell Phone Service: “Current Provider:” dropdown list is missing “Comcast”;
        #16. Cell Phone Service: “Current Provider:” dropdown list is missing “AT&T”;
        #17. Cell Phone Service: “Current Provider:” dropdown list: add “Other” option;
        #18. Cell Phone Service: “I am open to using different provider” label has grammar mistake (open to use OR open for using);
        #19. Cell Phone Service: "I am happy with my current provider" and "I am open to using different provider" checkboxes should be changed to radio buttons;
        #20. Cell Phone Service: “My monthly bill is approximately:” text field for amount in USD accepts letters;
        #21. Cell Phone Service: “My monthly bill is approximately:” text field should accept only up to 4 digits;
        #22. Cell Phone Service: “Months left on current contract:” dropdown list should consist up to 24 months. Months 11 and 12 are missing in the list.
        #23. Cell Phone Service: “Number of phones on plan:” dropdown list consists numbers from 1 to 100 and option “more”. Change up to 5 lines;

        #24. “2. Local/Long Distances/International Service” label; space after each slash “/”;
        #25. Local/Long Distances/International Service: “Current Provider:” dropdown list – provider names should be in alphabetical order;
        #26. Local/Long Distances/International Service: “Current Provider:” dropdown list is missing “T-Mobile”;
        #27. Local/Long Distances/International Service: “Current Provider:” dropdown list is missing “Nextel”;
        #28. Local/Long Distances/International Service: “Current Provider:” dropdown list: add “Other” option;
        #29. Local/Long Distances/International Service: “Primary Phone Number:” input fields have three cells. There is no jump from the first cell to the second and third ones after typing digits;
        #30. Local/Long Distances/International Service: “International calls included?” label ends with question mark “?” instead of colon “:”;

        #31. High Speed Internet Service: "Wireless Aircard" checkbox in "Type of service:" should be changed to a radio button;

        #32. TV Service: Provider names in “Current Provider:” dropdown list should be in alphabetical order;
        #33. TV Service: “Months left on plan:” dropdown list should have “more”;

        #34. Home Security Service: Provider names in “Current Provider:” dropdown list should be in alphabetical order;

        #35. Gas and Electric Services: Provider names in “Current Provider:” dropdown list should be in alphabetical order;
        #36. Gas and Electric Services: “I am opento using different provider” checkbox label has a grammar mistake “open to”;

        #37. Default input focus is disabled;
        #38. No default button assigned;
        #39. TAB order mistake: “First Name:”– “Referred by:” – “Last Name:”;
        #40. “Submit” button should be inactive if the required fields are not filled in;
        #41. "Clear" button doesn't clear the form;
        #42. "Clear" button invokes misleading error message "Error 17896 - Invalid data request. Please call technical support or restart your computer !!!";
        #43. Inconsistency between GUI implementation in between "Submit" and "Clear" buttons;
        #44. Wild cards accepted;
        I really like it how you made all clear

        Comment


        • #64
          1. «First Name» field accepts 30 characters max instead of 31/ field is limited to 30 characters instead of 31
          2. «Last Name» field accepts 30 characters max instead of 31
          3. «Street Address» field is limitid to 100 characters instead of 255
          4. Remove «BC» from «State» list box field
          5. «ZIP» field allows to enter non-digits but doesnt accept them.
          6. «Email» field accepts up to 1061 characters instead of 255
          7. «Email» field doesnt behave as required but it has asterisk assigned
          8. «Reffered by» behaves as a required field but it has no asterisk assigned
          9. «Phone» field allows to enter non-digits if you paste them but doesnt accept them after «Confirm» button is pushed
          10. Server side crash on exceeding the limit of characters accepted by «Comments» field
          11. Wild cards should not be accepted in test fields

          Comment


          • #65
            "Energy-Telecom Service Review" bug reports - using web form testing guidelines

            #1. Contact information: No default input focus
            #2. Contact information: Tab order is not correct
            #3. Contact information: The "Email" asterisk is blue instead of red
            #4. Contact information: The state "BC" should be removed from the list since this is US only.
            #5. Contact information: "IND" is not a state
            #6. Contact information: Under "State" drop box, "Other" should be removed
            #7. Cell Phone Service: "Current Provider" should have "Other" as a option
            #8. Cell Phone Service: In "Current Provider" drop box "AT&T" is missing.
            #9. Cell Phone Service: "My monthly bill is approximately" accepts letters
            #10. Local/Long Distances/International Service: Tab order is incorrect
            #11. High Speed Internet Service: Tab order is incorrect
            #12. TV Service: Tab order is incorrect
            #13. TV Service: The "Check boxes" are different sizes
            #14. Home Security Service: I can copy and paste letters into "My monthly bill is approximately:" field
            #15. Digital Phone Service with Video Phone: The check box is not aligned with all other check boxes
            #16. Gas and Electric Services: "I am opento using different provider" has a mispell error
            #17. Gas and Electric Services: "My monthly bill is approximately (summer):" accepts letter by copy and paste method
            #18. Gas and Electric Services: "My monthly bill is approximately (winter):"accepts letter by copy and paste method
            #19. Comments: An error will occur when pressing the "Clear" button which will be "Error 17896 - Invalid data request. Please call technical support or restart your computer !!!"
            #20. Comments: The "Submit" and "Clear" buttins have different fonts
            #21. Comments: You can go beyond the text limit by copy and paste method. The result, when pressing submit, will crash the web page with error "Request Entity Too Large"

            Comment


            • #66
              Testing software: web-page "Energy-Telecom Service Review" [http://www.energy-telecom.portnov.com/qa/]
              Test type: Review of the Energy-Telecom Online Form per requirements
              Date: 01/23/2018

              Used software:
              Windows 7 Pro 64bit
              Yandex Browser / Ver. 17.11.1.988

              All the testing is done on the web-page http://www.energy-telecom.portnov.com/qa/ hereinafter referred as "the page"


              Functionality testing based on requirements

              Section "Contact Information"
              #1. "First Name" text field accepts only 30 digits instead of 31
              #2. "Last Name" text field accepts only 30 digits instead of 31
              #3. "Street Address" edit box accepts only 100 digits instead of 255
              #4. "State" List Box contains only 49 states + "Other" string instead of the list of all 50 states.
              #5. "ZIP" text field accepts upper and lower case english letters instead of digits only.
              #6. "ZIP" text field accepts more then 5 characters, if they are not typed in but copy-pasted.
              #7. "Email" text field behaves like it is not required - the form can be submited without filling "Email" text field, and there is no expected error message.
              #8. "Email" text field accepts any characters, instead of "digits, letters, some special characters".
              #9. "Email" text field accepts up to 1063 characters, instead of only 255.
              #10. "Email" text field has no spell-checking for valid email address (like "ZIP" and "Phone" fields do).
              #11. "Phone" text field accepts any characters instead of digits only, if they are not typed in but copy-pasted.

              Section "1. Cell Phone Service"
              #12. "Current Provider" drop-down list does not contain the "Other" option like the rest drop-down lists on the page
              #13. Both checkboxes "I am happy with my current provider" and "I am open to using different provider" can be checked at the same time instead of disabling one another (can be replaced by radio buttons).
              #14. The check in the checkbox "I am happy with my current provider" does not disable the other elements in this section.
              #15. "My monthly bill is approximately" field allows to input letters instead of digits only.
              #16. "Minutes on plan" drop-down list contains very small number of possible values - the client's plan may not match any of them.
              #17. "Months left on current contract" drop-down list contains terms only up to 10 months - the client's plan may not match any of these terms
              #18. Both checkboxes "I like my handset" and "I am interested in updating my handset" can be checked at the same time instead of disabling one another (can be replaced by radio buttons).

              Section "4. TV Service"
              #19. "Months left on plan" drop-down list contains terms only up to 24 months - the client's plan may not match any of these terms
              #20. Section "6. Digital Phone Service with Video Phone"

              Section "7. Gas and Electric Services"
              #21. The title of the "I am opento using different provider" checkbox is misspelled" ("opento" instead of "open to").

              Section "8. Comments"
              #22. The field "8. Comments" has no limit for input symbols if they are not typed in but copy-pasted. Overfilling this field makes the webform crash when submitted.


              GUI testing based on GUI guidelines for WEB applications

              #23. Wrong tab order in the "Contact Information" section of the page: pressing Tab in the field "First Name" brings the cursor to the field "Referred by" and not to the field "Last Name" as logically intended.
              #24. No auto-tabbing is used in the "ZIP" field after entering 5 digits
              #25. "I am interested in Digital Phone Service (Unlimited Calling)" checkbox and its title are misaligned with the rest of similar elements on the page.
              #26. The "Submit" and "Clear" buttons have different size and are not aligned correctly.
              Last edited by Dva.Kompota; 01-23-2018, 06:10 AM.

              Comment


              • #67
                Energy-Telecom Service Review per requirements
                Mac OS Sierra 10.12.5 / Safari 10.1.1
                1) «First Name:» text field, accepts 30 instead 31 characters.
                2) «Last Name:» text field, accepts 30 instead 31 characters.
                3) «Street Address:» text field, accepts 100 instead 255 characters.
                4) «State:» List Box offering the list of 49 states and item «other» instead of 50 states.
                5) «ZIP:» text field, accepts digits and letters and except as many characters as you copy/past by mouse .
                6) «Email:» text field, accepts 1063 instead 255 characters and includes all instead some special characters.
                7) «Phone:» 3 text fields, accept all characters copy/pasting by mouse instead digits only.

                8) ’Referred by’ field doesn’t have a asterisk.
                9) «Clean» button doesn’t clean the forms (error - invalid data request)
                10) Form doesn’t clean even after «refresh the page» on Safari browser
                11) Except form without Email (»Email» field does not aloud like required field, asterisk doesn’t change the color)
                12) «My monthly bill is approximately:» field except all characters and it include 11 characters (to much for this field)
                13) «Primary phone number:» field accept all characters copy/pasting by mouse instead digits only.

                Comment


                • #68
                  'Energy-Telecom Service Review” bug report – using requirements and guidelines
                  macOS High Sierra 10.13.2
                  Safari Version 11.0.2 (13604.4.7.1.3)
                  http://www.energy-telecom.portnov.com/qa/index.php
                  Date: 01/28/2018


                  #01. Section “Contact Information” Field “First Name:” - accepts only 30 characters instead of 31.
                  #02. Section “Contact Information” Field “Last Name:” - accepts only 30 characters instead of 31.
                  #03. Section “Street Address” Field “Last Name:” - accepts only 100 characters instead of 255.
                  #04. Section “Street Address” Listbox “State:” - remove "BC" listbox item and add one missing state.
                  #05. Section “Street Address” Field “Zip:” - should accept only digits, but it accepts letters too.
                  #06. Section “Street Address” Field “Email:” - accepts 1063 characters instead of 255.
                  #07. Section “Street Address” Field “Email:” - does not behave as a required field. Able to submit form with empty field.
                  #08. Section “Street Address” Field “Referred by:” - behave as a required field but unmarked with “*”.
                  #9. Form - No default button.
                  #10. Section “1. Cell Phone Service” Radiobuttons “Bundled with:” - should have initial value.
                  #11. Section “2.Local/Long Distances/International Service” Radiobuttons “International calls included?” - should have initial value.
                  #11. Section “3. High Speed Internet Service” Field “Provider:” - should be presented as a listbox.
                  #12. Form - No default button.
                  #10. Section “1. Cell Phone Service” Months left on current contract:” - values from “11” to “24” need to be added (or value “more than 10”).
                  #11. Section “1. Cell Phone Service” Field ”My monthly bill is approximately:” - should accept only digits, but it accepts letters too.
                  #12. Form - “Clear” button - should clear the form but it shows message “Error 17896 - Invalid data request. Please call technical support or restart your computer !!!”



                  Questions about requirements
                  ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                  #01. Should not we have more required fields? Or just contact information is ok?
                  #02. Fields “My monthly bill is approximately:” in different sections - Should not we make List boxes with ranged values instead of text boxes?
                  Last edited by portpes; 01-28-2018, 11:10 PM.

                  Comment


                  • #69
                    1. "Contact information" section: "First name" field accepts no more than 30 characters instead of 31.
                    2. "Contact information" section: "Last name" field accepts no more than 30 characters instead of 31.
                    3. "Contact information" section: "Street Address" field accepts no more than 100 characters instead of 225.
                    4. "Contact information" section: "ZIP" field accepts more than 5 characters.
                    5. "Contact information" section: "ZIP" field should not accept non-digits.
                    6. "Contact information" section: remove "Other" option from "State" list box.
                    7. "Contact information" section: remove non US state "BC".
                    8. "Contact information" section: states HI and NV are missing in "State" list box.
                    9. "Contact information" section: "Email" field accepts more than 225 characters.
                    10. "Contact information" section: user should not be able to paste non-digits in the "Phone" field.
                    11. "Cell Phone Service" section: "I am happy with my current provider" checkbox should disable "I am open to using different provider" checkbox.
                    12. "Cell Phone Service" section: "Other" option is needed in "Current Provider" list box.
                    13. "Cell Phone Service" section: "My monthly bill is approximately:" should not accept non-digits.

                    Comment


                    • #70
                      #1. There is no default button
                      #2. Tab is not moving Left to Right and Top to Buttom order
                      #3. "Email" has an asterisk on the form but it is not listed in the requirements
                      #4. "Referred by" has no asterick on the form but is listed as required
                      #5. "State": "other" should be removed from listbox
                      #6. "State": 2 states are missing
                      #7. "State": non existing states(BC) are provided in the listbox
                      #8. "Zip code": accepts more than 5 digits
                      #9. "Zip code": accepts non digits
                      #10."Cell phone service": "other" option is missing in "current provider" listbox
                      #11. "Cell phone section": allows letters instead of digits only
                      #12. "Current provider": At&t is not listed
                      #13. "Monthly bill": the amount of digits allowed to provide is not logical.
                      #14. "Months left on the contract": provided only 10 instead of 24
                      #15. "Number of phones on plan": greater than accepted
                      #16. Checkboxes appear to be inconsistant
                      #17. "Gas and Electric services" section: Typo "opento"
                      #17. Clear button doesnt clear the form
                      #18. Error message popup after pushing Clear button
                      #19. "First name": accepts 30 characters instead of 31 required
                      #20. "Last name" : accepts 30 characters instead of 31 required
                      #21. "Street address": accepts no more than 100 instead of 255
                      #22. " Email": accepts more than 255 characters
                      #23. "State": 49 listed instead of 50

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X